Skip to content

move persistently_forall_2 out of BI interface

Ralf Jung requested to merge ralf/persistently-forall into master

This is a step towards #224: weaken the BI axioms such that IPM can support logics where the persistently modality is defined with an existential quantifier. This means we have to remove persistently_forall_2 and replace it by the weaker persistently_and_2 (so only finite conjunction can be commuted around <pers>). We also have to remove persistently_impl_plainly : (■ P → <pers> Q) ⊢ <pers> (■ P → Q) from BiPlainly -- I don't think this can be proven constructively for ∃-based <pers>, though there might be a classical proof.

I then added typeclasses so that logics that do enjoy the full set of properties can still exploit them. For users of uPred and its derivatives, there should be no changes.

Edited by Ralf Jung

Merge request reports